Xiaomi vs Fitbit | Mi Band 7 vs Fitbit Charge 5
Xiaomi vs Fitbit is a comparison of the most popular smartwatches on the market today. Read our review to see which one is right for you.
Xiaomi is known to shake up the market of any product they manufacture. They do this by offering products that are very competitive in performance and design while costing considerably lower. Another product segment that Xiaomi is trying to disrupt is the fitness trackers/smart band market.
Related: Xiaomi vs Garmin | Xiaomi Mi Watch vs Garmin Forerunner 55
The leader right in this segment is Fitbit and they have some very good products, but Xiaomi is aiming to offer the same or better experience and price their products aggressively so that customers choose them.
Let us see how both brands compare and how the most popular product from each brand compares against each other. This is Xiaomi vs Fitbit, this is Xiaomi Mi Smart Band 7 vs the Fitbit Charge 5.
Xiaomi vs Fitbit: Smart Band 7 vs Charge 5
| Physical Specs | Xiaomi Mi Band 7 | Fitbit Charge 5 |
|---|---|---|
| Physical size | 46.5 x 20.7 x 12.25mm | 36.78 x 22.79 x 11.2 mm |
| Material | Polycarbonate, silicone wristband | Aerospace grade aluminum case and Corning Gorilla Glass 3 display. The housing and buckle are made of anodized aluminum. |
| Display type | AMOLED touchscreen | AMOLED touchscreen |
| Display size | 1.62 inch | 1.04 inch |
| Display resolution | 326 PPI | 326 ppi |
| Battery life | Up to 15 days typical, 9 days heavy | Up to 7 days, or up to 5 hours with GPS |
| Water-resistance | 5 ATM | 5 ATM |
| Weight (core unit) | 13.5 grams | 15 grams |
| Sensors | Accelerometer, gyroscope, optical heart rate sensor, SpO2 | 3-axis accelerometer, Optical heart rate monitor, Pulse Ox, Multipurpose electrical sensors compatible with ECG app & EDA Scan app |
| GPS | Requires phone | Built-in GPS (support for 5 systems) |
| NFC | China-only | Yes |
Design and Build of the Xiaomi Smart Band 7 vs Fitbit Charge 5
In this comparison, we will look at the Xiaomi Mi Band 7 and the Fitbit Charge 5 fitness trackers.
One thing I noticed is that the Charge 5's module and screen are attached to a removable strap, which gives you more flexibility in terms of style and material. On the other hand, the Mi Band 5 has a strap that you can push the module and screen out of when you need to change it, which is quite convenient.
Another aspect I found intriguing is the difference in the customization options. The Charge 5 offers various styles and materials, allowing you to create a more elegant look, while the Mi Band 5 only offers different colored straps.
In terms of display, both trackers feature AMOLED touchscreen displays and support an always-on display mode. The Charge 5 has a wider screen compared to the Mi Band 5, but both offer high-quality displays with deep blacks, vibrant colors, and a good maximum level of brightness.
When it comes to durability, both trackers are waterproof and can be immersed in water up to 50 meters depth, making them suitable for pool swim tracking.
Lastly, I couldn't help but notice the sleek design of the Charge 5, which definitely caught my attention. However, it does come with a higher price tag compared to the Mi Band 5.
Overall, both the Charge 5 and the Mi Band 5 have their own unique features and benefits, making them great choices for anyone in search of a reliable fitness tracker.
Health Tracking Capabilities of the Xiaomi Smart Band 7 vs Fitbit Charge 5
After comparing the features of the Charge 5 and the Mi Band 7 and discovered some interesting differences.
Both trackers count steps, monitor heart rate, and track sleep. The Mi Band 7 also includes Xiaomi's PAI scores to encourage users to regularly raise their heart rate over the week. However, the Charge 5 uses Fitbit's PurePulse heart rate sensor, which is renowned for its superior tracking accuracy and data presentation, making it a reliable choice.
When it comes to sleep tracking, both trackers can track heart rate, breathing quality, and SpO2 data at night. But, the Charge 5 is more reliable, providing more accurate sleep data and insights.
The Mi Band 7 also includes additional features, such as women's health tracking, guided breathing exercises, stress, and SpO2 monitoring, making it an excellent health tracker. On the other hand, the Charge 5 has an ECG sensor, temperature sensor, and electrodermal activity sensor (EDA) to measure stress responses, making it an all-in-one fitness and health tracker.
Both the Charge 5 and the Mi Band 7 offer various health and fitness tracking features. But, if you're looking for a reliable and accurate fitness tracker, the Charge 5 may be a better option. If you want a comprehensive health tracker with additional features, the Mi Band 7 will be the one for you.
| Health & Fitness Tracking Metrics | Xiaomi Mi Band 7 | Fitbit Charge 5 |
|---|---|---|
| Daily Readiness Score | No | Yes |
| Electrocardiogram (ECG) | No | Yes |
| Electrodermal Activity (EDA) | No | Yes |
| Heart Rate Variability | No | Yes |
| Irregular Heart Rhythm Notifications | No | Yes |
| NFC | China only | Yes |
| PAI | Yes | No |
| Relaxation breathing reminder | Yes | No |
| Skin Temperature | No | Yes |
| SpO2 | Continuous and spot checking | During sleep only |
| Workout modes | 120 | 20 |
Sports Tracking Features of the Xiaomi Smart Band 7 vs Fitbit Charge 5
In terms of sports tracking, the Charge 5 has built-in GPS, while the Mi Band 7 only offers connected GPS. Fitbit offers 20 exercise modes, including automatic exercise recognition for activities like running, walking, and pool swimming.
It also offers features like workout intensity maps, Active Zone Minutes, Cardio Fitness score, and Daily Readiness scores (with Fitbit Premium). Both trackers are excellent at tracking exercise, but the Charge 5 offers more features in this area.
Additionally, the Charge 5 comes with Fitbit's Active Zone Minutes feature, which aims to motivate users to hit their target heart rate zone during workouts and offers personalized on-screen workout guidance and can track your pace and distance when using its built-in GPS.
On the other hand, the Mi Band 7 offers over 30 exercise modes, including outdoor running, cycling, and swimming. There's even an automatic workout detection mode for six activities, including running and cycling. However, its lack of built-in GPS means that it needs to be connected to your phone to track your route.
Both trackers can track your steps, calories burned, and distance covered, and offer real-time stats during your workouts. They are also water-resistant and can track swimming activities, making them suitable for water sports enthusiasts.
Does the Xiaomi Smart Band 7 or the Fitbit Charge 5 Offer Better Battery Performance?
One of the standout features of the Xiaomi smart band is its impressive battery life. I can go up to two weeks on a single charge, and a quick 30-minute top-up every few days keeps it going indefinitely. This is a huge advantage for me, as I don't have to worry about constantly charging my Xiaomi Smart Band.
On the other hand, Fitbit boasts advanced sensors that give me detailed insights into my workouts and daily activity. However, the battery life is not as long as the Xiaomi smart band. With GPS switched on, I can expect around 5 hours on a single charge, which may not be enough for some users.
Which Fitness Tracker is Better: Xiaomi Smart Band 7 or Fitbit Charge 5?
Overall, if you're looking for a fitness tracker with comprehensive sports tracking features and built-in GPS, the Fitbit Charge 5 is the better choice. However, if you don't mind relying on your phone's GPS and want a wider range of exercise modes, the Xiaomi Mi Band 7 could be a more cost-effective option.
Xiaomi vs Fitbit: Band 5 vs Inspire HR
Xiaomi vs Fitbit - Specifications
| | Xiaomi Mi Band 5 | Fitbit Inspire HR |
| Screen size | 1.1-inch AMOLED Color display | 1-inch OLED Greyscale display |
| Screen resolution | 126 x 294 Pixels | 128 x 72 pixels |
| Water resistance | 5ATM, Up to 50 meters | 5ATM, Up to 50 meters |
| Sensors | Accelerometer, gyroscope, PPG heart rate sensor, and barometer | Accelerometer, Optical heart rate sensor |
| Sleep Tracking | Yes | Yes |
| Batterysize | 110mAh | N/A |
| Battery life | Up to 14 days (non-NFC version) | Up to 10 days |
| Phone compatibility | Android and iOS | Android, iOS and Windows 10 |
| Sports modes | 11 | 20 |
| Active Zone Minutes | No | Yes |
| Guided Breathing | Yes | Yes |
| Female Health Tracking | Yes | Yes |
| GPS | No (can use a smartphone) | No (can use a smartphone) |
Design and Build of Mi Band vs FITBIT
Fitbit has been in the game of fitness trackers for quite a long time now. But since their first few designs, I feel like they have failed to innovate in terms of design.
All fitness trackers in the market look similar, and you can mistake one for another easily. There are many Fitbit-like smart bands, making Fitbit’s design feel generic and not so exciting.
On the other hand, Xiaomi has been sticking to the same smart band design for two generations. This brings up the same argument of it not being anything exciting or unique. But on the plus side, both smart bands from Fitbit or Xiaomi don’t have bad designs, they are just uninspiring.
Just based on design, I would choose the Fitbit Inspire HR over the Xiaomi Smart Band 5 as I like the boxy display of the Inspire HR over the Mi Smart Band 5’s pill-like looks.
Fitbit also offers tons of first-party bands for all its fitness trackers, which allows for easy personalization of your Inspire HR. You can get third-party bands for Xiaomi’s smart bands but you will need to do a lot of research for it.
Both Fitbit and Xiaomi fitness trackers are designed similarly. The main device is detachable from the bands and these bands are replaceable too. Xiaomi requires you to remove the bands before you can charge the device while you don’t have to worry about the band on the Fitbit Inspire HR when it comes to charging.
Exterior design isn’t everything for a smart band, the design also incorporates the screen of the smart bands, and here Fitbit falls behind quite a lot. Fitbit uses a grayscale OLED display on the Inspire HR, which is fine in its own right, but when you place it next to the gorgeous 1.1 inch AMOLED color display of the Xiaomi’s Smart Band 5, you’ll feel a bit jealous, maybe a lot.
Check out the Xiaomi Mi Band 5 & 6 on Aliexpress
Check out the Fitbit Inspire on Amazon
Fitness Tracking of Mi Band vs Fitbit
Fitness and sports tracking are the reasons these devices exist. And in the case of Fitbit, the company itself exists because of fitness and sports tracking. Xiaomi, on the other hand, is expanding its product segment while wanting to capture a share of the market.
Fitbit has been the pioneer when it comes to fitness tracking bands, while Xiaomi is relatively a newcomer to the market.
Fitbit fits in an accelerometer and a heart rate sensor into all of its smart bands, while Xiaomi has managed to find the space to include an accelerometer, a heart rate sensor, and a barometer too.
So if you are someone who treks or climbs a lot, then Xiaomi would be the brand for you. The accelerometer is used to measure the distance traveled.
With the help of the heart rate sensor, both Xiaomi and Fitbit can track sleep and offer insights into things like sleep quality and more.
The heart rate sensor also offers guided breathing exercises, the ability to detect heart rate abnormalities, and more. Both smart bands take and store readings over a week and give detailed info on your heart rate and sleep.
When comparing the Mi Smart Band 5 and Fitbit Inspire HR, I found that both tracked sleep well and provided good insight into the quality of sleep and other seep metrics. The guided breathing exercises and collection of heart rate readings were fairly accurate from both devices.
And when it came to step-tracking, both devices offered reliable step tracking, making them both a good choice for fitness tracking overall.
Both Xiaomi and Fitbit offer women’s health tracking features too which can be accessed from their companion apps.
Sport and Activity Tracking of Mi Band vs Fitbit
When it comes to sports tracking, Xiaomi offers dedicated modes for running (indoors and outdoors) cycling, swimming, walking, and a general without mode.
All these activities are tracked and recorded using the accelerometer. When connected to your smartphone, the Mi Band 5 can take advantage of your smartphone’s GPS for activities like running and cycling.
Fitbit uses a similar approach too when it comes to sports and activities tracking, but here, Fitbit offers much more than Xiaomi. You can use Inspire HR to measure and record running, cycling, treadmill running, weight lifting, workouts, swimming, tennis, stair climbing, hiking, yoga, martial arts, and more.
Sport and activity tracking is where Fitbit shines and uses all its expertise to offer a much better experience than the Xiaomi Mi Smart Band 5. The Inspire HR like the Mi Smart Band 5 also takes advantage of your smartphone’s GPS for outdoor activities.
From testing, the accuracy of the Mi Band 5’s run tracking was very accurate, especially when connected to your smartphone’s GPS. The Mi Band 5 is also reliable when it comes to swimming, and it is a welcome improvement over the previous Mi Band.
Fitbit on the other hand has decent run tracking but does show the distance to be lower than expected or compared to some other devices. Fitbit can also automatically recognize between different activities like walking, running, swimming, and cycling which Xiaomi smart bands can’t, which is a very good feature.
Fitbit offers a lot of data, but Xiaomi tends to offer better data here and the color screen also makes it great to use and compare these data.
Smartwatch Features of Mi Band vs Fitbit
These fitness trackers can also double down as smartwatches but their functionality is limited compared to a full-blown smartwatch.
Both Fitbit and Xiaomi offer app notifications from a paired smartphone, vibration alarms, and offer multiple watch faces. Since Xiaomi uses a color display, it comes with better and more fun watch faces too.
For the above purposes, I would even call it a draw between the Fitbit Inspire HR and the Xiaomi Mi Smart Band 5. But Xiaomi being a smartphone manufacturing giant, they have a lot of tricks up their sleeves to make the Mi Smart Band 5 probably the smartest fitness band out there.
Xiaomi offers tons of customization options on the Mi Smart Band 5 to personalize each band and make them truly yours. Fitbit does offer customizability but it is very limited and the grayscale display doesn’t help either.
The Mi Smart Band 5 also offers custom patterns, vibrations, and notifications for different apps and functions. You can set schedules on the Mi Smart Band 5, control music, a night mode, and even a ‘Find my Band’ feature.
If you live in China, you have access to more features. You can get the ability to make contactless payments with Alipay and get access to Xiaomi’s Xiao AI assistant.
So when it comes to smartwatch features and functionality, then there is no contest, to be honest, the Mi Smart Band 5 is the winner. And the color screen just makes it so much better.
Check out the Xiaomi Mi Band 5 & 6 on Aliexpress
Check out the Fitbit Inspire on Amazon
Battery Life of Mi Band vs Fitbit
Both brands also share a similarity when it comes to battery and charging, but this time it’s a negative one. They come with terrible charging cables that are small, and feel very cheap. And given that the Fitbit at least 3 times more, it should have come with a better cable.
A small positive is that these devices can last for days o a single charge so you don’t have to use those terrible chargers very often. The Fitbit Inspire HR can last up to 5 days which is impressive in itself, but the Mi band 5 can last up to a whopping 20 days making it the clear winner. This measurement is with the heart rate sensors turned on.
Verdict
This is an easy comparison and it is also easy to recommend one product over the other. When comparing the brands themselves,
Fitbit sure does have an advantage as they have been the primary player in the fitness tracker industry. This shows in the number of activities their bands can track and the automatic tracking feature. Xiaomi is eating up Fitbit’s market share by offering fitness trackers that are smart and affordable.
I would recommend the Xiaomi Mi Smart Band 5 over the Fitbit Inspire HR. The Mi Smart Band 5 comes with a much better screen and battery life too. The Mi Smart Band 5 is also very accurate and is similar to the Inspire HR when you compare tracking performance.
Fitbit is a bit better when it comes to design and tracking modes, but for the everyday user, a colorful, vibrant screen and much better battery life will be more useful.
And finally, the Mi Smart Band 5 is just a fraction of the cost at 33$ compared to Inspire HR’s 80$ current price tag. This makes it a no-brainer, the Mi Smart Band 5 should be the choice for anyone, as the Inspire HR doesn’t offer any feature to justify the price tag.
FAQs
What is the best alternative to Fitbit?
Does Fitbit connect to Xiaomi?
Can I use Fitbit without a phone?
Also Read: